Achievable logo
Achievable blue logo on white background
  • Reading
  • /How online reviews influence sales: a guide for retailers

How online reviews influence sales: a guide for retailers

What research shows about how online reviews influence sales, from star ratings to the first five reviews, and how retailers can collect more reviews within the FTC’s rules.
Achievable's profile picture
Achievable
16 Nov 2026, 5 min read
Achievable blue logo on white background
  • Reading
  • /How online reviews influence sales: a guide for retailers

Online reviews are one of the strongest influences on whether a shopper buys. In a landmark study by Northwestern University’s Spiegel Research Center and the reviews company PowerReviews, a product with five reviews was 270% more likely to be purchased than a product with none, and nearly 95% of shoppers said they read reviews before buying. This guide covers what that research found, what it means for retailers, and how to collect reviews within today’s rules.

Why online reviews matter

Shoppers see reviews as honest opinions from people like them, so reviews act as social proof. They answer questions a product description can’t, such as whether something fits, lasts or is worth the price, and they reduce the risk of buying something you can’t see or touch.

The Spiegel Research Center study analyzed millions of customer interactions at three online retailers: two selling mostly lower-priced consumer products and one selling high-end gifts. Its findings remain some of the most practical guidance available on how reviews drive sales.

Key findings on how reviews influence sales

1. Reviews matter more for expensive items

At the gift retailer, displaying reviews raised the conversion rate by 190% for lower-priced products and by 380% for higher-priced ones. When a purchase costs more, shoppers research more and lean harder on reviews to manage the risk.

2. Reviews matter more for high-consideration products

Price isn’t the only thing that makes a purchase feel risky. Reviews had a bigger effect on products shoppers think harder about, such as items that affect their health, express their identity or will be bought again and again. Expensive, high-consideration products are where reviews matter most.

3. A perfect 5.0 rating can look too good to be true

Higher ratings generally sell better, but only up to a point. Purchase likelihood typically peaked for ratings between 4.0 and 4.7, and products rated 4.7 to 5.0 were less likely to be bought than those rated 4.2 to 4.7. Shoppers grow suspicious of perfection. Negative reviews help here: PowerReviews research cited in the study found that 82% of shoppers specifically seek out negative reviews.

4. Your first reviews have the biggest impact

Nearly all of the increase in purchase likelihood came within a product’s first 10 reviews, and the first five drove most of it. Higher-priced items needed at least five reviews to see the full effect, while lower-priced items saw a significant lift from just two to four.

5. Verified buyers give higher ratings and are trusted more

In the study, verified buyers were customers who bought online and then received an email asking them to review their purchase. Their reviews averaged 4.34 stars, compared with 3.89 for anonymous reviewers, largely because people who review without being asked tend to have more extreme, and often more negative, experiences. Shoppers also trusted verified reviews more: seeing a review from a verified buyer instead of an anonymous one raised purchase likelihood by 15%.

Recommendations for retailers

1. Display reviews and star ratings prominently

Show the star rating and review count near the product name and price, on category pages and on mobile, where most shopping now starts. Let shoppers sort and filter reviews, and surface the most helpful ones.

2. Get every product to its first five to ten reviews

That’s where most of the lift happens, so focus on new products and items with few or no reviews. Follow-up emails do most of the work: PowerReviews data cited in the study found that up to 80% of reviews came from post-purchase emails asking for one. Send the request after the customer has had time to use the product, and make leaving a review take only a few taps on any device. Product sampling programs can also generate early reviews for new items.

3. Focus extra effort on expensive and high-consideration products

Big-ticket items, new brands and products that affect health or safety benefit most from reviews. Prioritize review requests and reminders in these categories, and encourage detailed reviews, including photos, that answer the questions shoppers ask most.

4. Embrace negative reviews and respond to them

Don’t hide honest negative reviews. A mix of ratings makes the positive ones believable and shows you represent your products honestly. Respond promptly and professionally, fix the problem when you can, and use recurring complaints to improve your products and descriptions.

5. Ask every buyer, and badge verified reviews

Inviting every verified buyer to leave a review, not just the happy ones, raises both your average rating and the credibility of your reviews. Mark reviews from confirmed purchasers with a “verified buyer” badge.

Collect reviews within the rules

The rules on reviews have tightened since the Spiegel research. In 2024 the Federal Trade Commission finalized a rule banning fake reviews and testimonials. It took effect in October 2024 and lets the FTC seek civil penalties from knowing violators. Under the rule, businesses can’t:

  • Write, buy or sell fake reviews, including AI-generated ones or reviews from people who never used the product
  • Offer compensation or incentives on the condition that a review is positive (or negative)
  • Post reviews from employees or other insiders without clearly disclosing the connection
  • Suppress negative reviews through threats, intimidation or baseless legal action, or present a filtered set of reviews as if it were all of them
  • Buy or sell fake followers or views to look more popular

Incentives that don’t depend on what the review says aren’t banned by the rule, but the connection should be disclosed, and many review platforms go further. Google’s policies for Maps reviews don’t allow businesses to offer incentives for reviews or to selectively ask only happy customers for them, and Amazon prohibits paid or incentivized reviews outside its own Vine program. Ask every customer the same way, and check the rules of each platform where your reviews appear.

Key takeaways

  • Reviews drive sales: in the Spiegel study, five reviews made a product 270% more likely to be purchased than none.
  • Reviews matter most for expensive and high-consideration products.
  • Ratings between about 4.0 and 4.7 convert best, and some negative reviews build trust.
  • The first five to ten reviews deliver most of the lift, so prioritize products with few reviews.
  • Ask every verified buyer for a review, never pay for positive ones, and follow the FTC’s rule and each platform’s policies.
Achievable's profile picture
Achievable
16 Nov 2026, 5 min read
Achievable blue logo on white background

More reading

All reading

12 common dog breeds and their health issues

The health problems 12 common dog breeds are prone to, from hip dysplasia in Labradors to breathing trouble in pugs, and what owners can do to prevent or catch them early.

15 office design tricks that will increase your productivity at work

Fifteen office design changes, from natural light and ergonomic furniture to noise control and storage, that help you focus and get more done at work or at home.

15 office organization tips to help you get more done

Fifteen practical office organization tips for your desk, paperwork, digital files and daily routine, so you spend less time searching and more time getting work done.

Choosing sunglasses: Is UV protection important?

Why UV protection is the most important feature of sunglasses, how UV light damages your eyes, and what to look for on the label, from UV400 to lens size and polarization.

How to edit your hosts file on Windows, Mac, or Linux

Step-by-step instructions for editing the hosts file on Windows, macOS and Linux to block websites, test a server or troubleshoot DNS, plus how to apply changes safely.

How to manage stress and anxiety

Learn the signs of stress, healthy ways to cope with it day to day, when stress and anxiety call for professional help, and free resources you can use right now.

How to start mining cryptocurrency: a beginner’s guide

How cryptocurrency mining works, what it takes to mine Bitcoin, Litecoin, Dogecoin, Zcash and Monero today, why Ethereum can no longer be mined, and the costs and risks to weigh first.

The concise guide to writing SMART goals

What SMART stands for, the questions that test each letter, and a worked example that turns a vague goal into a specific, measurable plan with a deadline.

Yoga for anxiety and depression: what research shows and how to start

What research says about yoga for stress, anxiety and depression, why it may help, and a simple breathing technique plus eight beginner poses to get started safely.