
From the MCAT to USMLE Step 1: Which study habits carry over and what needs to change




Ryan Brownlee is a medical student, researcher, and founder of AspiringMD, a free educational platform dedicated to helping premedical students navigate the journey to medical school. His research focuses on oncology and clinical medicine, with multiple peer-reviewed publications and presentations at conferences.
Ryan is passionate about making medical education more accessible through practical study strategies, mentorship, and evidence-based guidance. Through his writing, he shares lessons from his own experiences to help aspiring physicians approach the MCAT, medical school admissions, and medical education with greater confidence.
Table of contents
- MCAT vs. USMLE Step 1: how studying for each exam differs
- How I studied for the MCAT: schedule, resources and practice exams
- Start with a diagnostic exam
- MCAT content review and Anki
- Learning through UWorld questions and Blueprint practice exams
- Transitioning to AAMC practice materials
- What I would do differently if I studied for the MCAT again
- Spend less time reading passively and more on active recall
- Review the whole concept, not just the question you missed
- Practice under realistic testing conditions
- How I studied for USMLE Step 1 throughout medical school
- Using AnKing, Boards and Beyond and Sketchy
- Starting UWorld and reviewing Step 1 practice questions
- Using NBME practice exams to find weak areas
- Which MCAT study habits carry over to Step 1
- What needs to change when you move from the MCAT to Step 1
- Building better study habits from the MCAT to medical school
- Key takeaways
Most of my MCAT study habits carried over to USMLE Step 1: active recall, spaced repetition, practice questions and a written system for reviewing my mistakes. What changed was the scale. I could treat the MCAT as a several-month project, but Step 1 meant keeping material fresh across the whole preclerkship curriculum while learning something new every week.
Here is how I prepared for both exams, which habits I kept, and what I would do differently if I started over. Whether you are about to start medical school or are a premed curious about what comes next, I hope my experience makes the transition feel a little less unfamiliar.
MCAT vs. USMLE Step 1: how studying for each exam differs
For most premed students, the first major hurdle is the Medical College Admission Test (MCAT), often taken during junior year of college or shortly before applying to medical school. Once you are in medical school, you face the United States Medical Licensing Examination (USMLE) series: Step 1 and Step 2 CK during medical school, then Step 3, typically during residency.
The MCAT mostly tests material from your undergraduate prerequisites: biology, biochemistry, general chemistry, organic chemistry, physics, psychology and sociology. It has four sections: Chemical and Physical Foundations of Biological Systems (Chem/Phys), Critical Analysis and Reasoning Skills (CARS), Biological and Biochemical Foundations of Living Systems (Bio/Biochem), and Psychological, Social, and Biological Foundations of Behavior (Psych/Soc). The science matters, but so does interpreting passages, analyzing experiments and applying concepts to unfamiliar situations. If you are still learning the differences between the sections, Achievable has a breakdown of the MCAT sections and study strategies for each.
Step 1 covers the foundational sciences behind health, disease and treatment. Instead of a chemistry experiment or a CARS passage, you get a clinical vignette: a patient with a set of symptoms, laboratory findings or imaging results. From there you might have to name the disease, explain its pathophysiology, recognize a histological finding or identify a medication’s mechanism of action. It still rewards critical thinking over memorizing facts, but the amount of medical information you are expected to know, retain and connect is far greater than on the MCAT. Achievable’s USMLE Step 1 exam guide lays out the format.
That difference in volume was the biggest adjustment for me. Despite it, the overall structure of my studying stayed similar.
How I studied for the MCAT: schedule, resources and practice exams
If you have read much MCAT advice on Reddit or Student Doctor Network, you have probably noticed that many people follow the same progression: content review, then third-party practice questions, then official AAMC practice materials. That is the structure I followed, and looking back it gave me a great foundation.
I took the MCAT in May of my junior year and started preparing the previous October. That gave me as much time as possible without delaying my medical school application, while I balanced studying with classes and other commitments. If you are deciding when to test and how to fit in the studying, my MCAT preparation and resource guide on AspiringMD collects timelines, study strategies and free resources, and Achievable’s guide to creating an MCAT study schedule walks through building a plan. A structured plan made it much easier for me to stay consistent while everything else was going on.
Start with a diagnostic exam
One of the most helpful early decisions I made was taking a diagnostic practice exam before starting content review. Many test prep companies offer a free one. The initial score shows your strengths and weaknesses, but I found something else more valuable: an early look at the kinds of questions the MCAT actually asks.
Knowing the format, question style and expectations let me approach content review on purpose, instead of trying to relearn every detail from my undergraduate courses.
MCAT content review and Anki
After the diagnostic I moved into content review with the Kaplan MCAT review books, supplemented by Khan Academy’s MCAT videos. I spent about six weeks working through the major subjects, reviewing several of them each day in separate study blocks. That is interleaving: alternating between subjects instead of studying one for a long stretch. Switching kept my studying engaging and gave me repeated chances to revisit different concepts.
Alongside content review I started using Anki, a flashcard app that uses spaced repetition to help you retain information over time. Rather than build every card myself, I mostly used the premade MileDown MCAT deck, and briefly experimented with the JackSparrow deck. My goal was 75 to 100 new cards a day on top of the cards already due. It quickly became a core part of my routine because it kept older material fresh while I learned new concepts. I did not yet appreciate how valuable that habit would be in medical school.
Learning through UWorld questions and Blueprint practice exams
After the first pass of content review, I moved into what I consider the most valuable part of my preparation: applying concepts through practice questions. I used the UWorld MCAT question bank alongside Blueprint full-length practice exams. To keep the schedule manageable, I divided the number of UWorld questions I wanted to finish by the days available before switching to AAMC materials, which gave me a daily question goal. I also scheduled a Blueprint full-length exam about every two to three weeks to check my progress and find areas that needed more attention.
Completing questions was only part of the learning, though. The real improvement came from understanding why I missed them. I kept an Excel spreadsheet of missed questions, why I got each one wrong and the concepts I needed to review, and I used the same system for UWorld questions and full-length exams. Reviewing one question took a few minutes; reviewing a full-length exam often took a full day. After finishing a review, I worked through the concepts I had missed, which helped me see recurring weaknesses and decide where to focus next.
If you are preparing for the MCAT, I recommend building some kind of structured review system. Achievable has a good article on reviewing MCAT practice exams and learning from your mistakes.
Transitioning to AAMC practice materials
About five weeks before my exam, I switched from third-party questions to the official AAMC practice materials. I started with the Question Packs, which gave me more practice across a broad range of subjects, then moved to the harder Section Bank questions. As test day approached I focused more and more on full-length exams to judge my readiness and get comfortable with the timing. I kept the same review process throughout, working through every missed question and writing down what to improve.
My last two to three weeks of preparation overlapped with the end of my spring semester, so I could give nearly all my attention to studying. I had planned that around my exam date on purpose, and it worked well.
Toward the end I sometimes took full-length exams only a few days apart. Looking back, I would leave more time between them to review mistakes and fix remaining weaknesses. I would also judge readiness by consistency: practice scores comfortably above your target score, across several full-length exams, rather than one good day.
What I would do differently if I studied for the MCAT again
I do not think my original approach was bad, but after going through medical school I would change three things.
Spend less time reading passively and more on active recall
I would cut back significantly on textbook reading during content review. Working through the Kaplan books took a long time, and I often felt I was not retaining information as efficiently as I could. After starting medical school and learning more about evidence-based study strategies, I became much more deliberate about active recall and spaced repetition instead of reading and rereading notes.
That does not make textbooks bad. They are very helpful when you are stuck on a difficult concept or need a more detailed explanation. But I found that using Anki and practice questions to test my understanding was a better use of time than rereading material I had already covered. If I started over, I would introduce active recall much earlier, use concise explanations or videos to fill gaps, and spend more time applying what I learned.
Review the whole concept, not just the question you missed
During MCAT prep I treated UWorld questions as a way to find a single missing fact. Once I understood why the correct answer was right, I wrote it down and moved on. In medical school I learned that it is usually more valuable to explore the concepts around the detail being tested.
For example, if I missed an MCAT question about enzyme inhibition, I would not just memorize the type of inhibition involved. I would revisit the different inhibition mechanisms, their effects on enzyme kinetics and how those relationships might look in a graph or an experimental passage. That takes more time up front, but it builds a much stronger understanding, and it prepares you to answer questions about the same concept even when the exam presents it in an unfamiliar way.
Practice under realistic testing conditions
One of my biggest regrets was not making my practice exams more like the real thing. I took most of my full-lengths in a quiet dorm room, whenever they fit my schedule. I was not always strict about breaks, and I sometimes checked my phone between sections. These seemed like small things.
At the testing center the experience was different: other examinees entering and leaving the room, background noise, security procedures during breaks, and restrictions on when I could reach my phone or belongings. I also was not used to the noise-reducing headphones or earplugs available there. None of it was a major problem alone, but together they were distractions I had not prepared for.
If I did it again, I would take more of my practice exams under realistic conditions: timed breaks, no phone, and a setting that is not completely silent. I would also try earplugs ahead of time to see whether they help me concentrate. I would not change my overall timeline, only how I approached those practice exam days.
How I studied for USMLE Step 1 throughout medical school
When I started medical school, I quickly saw that Step 1 would demand a different level of consistency. The MCAT had a defined study period that began a few months before test day. Step 1 preparation was something I built into my routine from the first weeks of medical school.
Older students kept stressing the importance of reviewing what you have already learned while taking in new material. It made sense: with so much content, forgetting an entire organ system and having to relearn it months later would cost far more time. So I made long-term retention a priority throughout preclerkship.
Using AnKing, Boards and Beyond and Sketchy
Anki became the foundation of my medical school routine, and I relied on it far more than I had for the MCAT. I switched from MileDown to the AnKing Step deck, a premade collection of flashcards covering a huge amount of medical school content, and reviewed it consistently while learning new material. Some days I completed close to 1,000 cards between new material and scheduled reviews.
That number may sound intimidating if you are still preparing for the MCAT. It was simply the workload I built up over time, not a target every medical student needs to hit. What mattered was a sustainable routine that let me retain information without constantly relearning it.
Our school also gave weekly quizzes on that week’s lectures. To prepare, many of us used third-party resources such as Boards and Beyond and Sketchy, which explain similar concepts with an emphasis on what is commonly tested on Step 1. They condense complex subjects into manageable lessons, and I could change the playback speed to move quickly through familiar material and slow down for difficult concepts.
My routine became simple: learn the material from lectures or videos, reinforce it with Anki, and keep reviewing older concepts while moving through new ones.
Starting UWorld and reviewing Step 1 practice questions
About six to eight months before my Step 1 exam, I added the UWorld Step 1 question bank. It was familiar territory, but my approach to reviewing questions had changed a lot. Instead of finding the right answer and recording a missing fact, I tried to understand the whole clinical or scientific concept being tested. If I missed a question about a disease, I considered its pathophysiology, characteristic symptoms, diagnostic findings and treatment mechanisms.
When I needed more explanation I turned to a Boards and Beyond or Sketchy video, and occasionally a YouTube video for a different take on a hard concept. I also created or unsuspended Anki cards for information I missed, so my weaknesses became part of my daily review instead of something I studied once and hoped to remember.
I also thought about how the same condition could appear in different clinical scenarios. One question might ask for the most likely diagnosis, another for the underlying mechanism, a characteristic microscopic finding or an associated medication. That moved me away from memorizing individual explanations and toward a fuller understanding of the material.
Using NBME practice exams to find weak areas
Throughout our preclerkship curriculum we also took NBME assessments at regular intervals, which let us measure our progress well before the real Step 1. As with AAMC exams during MCAT prep, I treated them as checkpoints rather than tests to get through. After each one we received performance information organized by subject and content category, with comparisons to other students. I used those reports to find weaknesses and decide which topics deserved more attention over the following weeks.
If I kept underperforming in one organ system, for example, I could prioritize more practice questions, revisit the relevant videos and strengthen my Anki reviews in that area. As Step 1 approached, I took additional practice assessments to check whether my studying was heading in the right direction.
If you are just starting medical school, Achievable’s 12-month USMLE Step 1 study plan is another useful perspective on combining content review, practice questions and spaced repetition over a long stretch.
Which MCAT study habits carry over to Step 1
I was surprised by how much of my MCAT strategy carried over. I still relied on content review, practice questions and official assessments to guide my preparation. The biggest difference was how consistently I used these methods and how much I adapted them to medical school.
- Active recall and spaced repetition. Anki had already helped me retain information for the MCAT, and it became even more valuable when I had to remember material across multiple semesters. I could keep revisiting a topic at scheduled intervals while learning new material.
- Practice questions. Whether for the MCAT or Step 1, answering questions forced me to apply what I knew and exposed weaknesses that content review alone missed.
- Practice exams as a measure of progress. I kept using them to evaluate my preparation and adjust my plan, instead of relying on how prepared I felt.
- A system for reviewing mistakes. The Excel spreadsheet from my MCAT prep grew into a broader system of targeted videos, extra questions and Anki cards. The tools changed, but the habit stayed the same: identify what went wrong, understand why, and make a plan to avoid repeating it.
I did not need to learn a new way of studying when I started medical school. I needed to build on the strategies I already had.
What needs to change when you move from the MCAT to Step 1
While many of my habits stayed the same, Step 1 required four adjustments that I think incoming medical students should know about.
- From a short-term schedule to a long-term review routine. MCAT prep gave me several months devoted to one exam. In medical school I had to retain material from the first day of preclerkship while learning new subjects every week. Reviewing older material became a daily habit instead of something I saved for the weeks before an exam. I still forgot things and had to revisit hard concepts, but consistent review cut the time I spent relearning from scratch.
- Being more selective with resources. I moved away from traditional textbooks for most of my studying and prioritized concise, Step-focused videos, Anki and practice questions, so I spent less time reviewing passively and more time testing my understanding. There were still times to slow down and go deeper on a topic. But using more resources did not mean I was learning more effectively, and sticking with a few familiar ones let me study more consistently and avoid repetition.
- Connecting information across subjects and clinical presentations. In the MCAT I thought of chemistry, biology and psychology as separate areas. In medical school I had to connect pathology, physiology, pharmacology, microbiology and more to understand one clinical problem. A cardiovascular condition, for example, can require normal physiology, the disease mechanism, characteristic findings and how a medication changes that process. That skill became essential for Step 1 practice questions.
- Checking your habits regularly. Do not assume that what worked before will keep working. When I kept missing questions in one subject, I asked whether the problem was a knowledge gap, difficulty applying information or how I was approaching the question. Sometimes the answer was more videos. Other times it meant changing how I reviewed Anki cards, doing more practice questions or spending more time on a difficult concept.
Step 1 is now reported as pass/fail only, but that does not make an effective study strategy any less important. A strong foundation in preclerkship helps prepare you for Step 1 and also for clinical rotations, Step 2 CK and eventually your work with patients.
Building better study habits from the MCAT to medical school
Your study methods should keep evolving as you move through your medical education. I can name plenty of things I would change about my MCAT preparation: less passive textbook reading, deeper review of missed questions and more practice exams under realistic conditions. But I would not change its overall structure, because it built habits that kept serving me in medical school.
When I moved to Step 1, I did not abandon those habits. I became more consistent with spaced repetition, relied more on active recall, and learned to treat practice questions as chances to understand whole concepts instead of memorizing individual answers.
You also do not need a perfect study system from the beginning. Mine was not perfect, and I kept adjusting it based on what was working. What worked for me may not be exactly what works for you, and that is completely okay. Stay curious about how you learn, notice which strategies help you retain information, be willing to change what is not working, and learn from students who have already been through the process.
Key takeaways
- Active recall, spaced repetition, practice questions and a written mistake-review system worked for both the MCAT and Step 1.
- The biggest change is time horizon: the MCAT is a months-long project, while Step 1 preparation is a daily review routine that starts with your first medical school lectures.
- Start with a diagnostic exam, and review each missed question by studying the whole concept behind it, not just the one detail.
- Practice under realistic conditions, with timed breaks, no phone and some background noise, and judge readiness by consistent practice scores above your target across several full-length exams.
- Use fewer resources more consistently, and check regularly whether your approach is still working.

