
How to get recruited for college sports





Monica Holmes is the founder of Movement Consulting, which gives high school athletes an honest evaluation of their skills and helps families navigate college recruiting, with timelines based on each student's grade, test scores, and ability. She has coached college volleyball for more than 20 years: at Santa Monica College, as an assistant coach at Hofstra University and the University of Illinois, as head women's volleyball coach at Columbia University for four seasons, as an assistant coach at the U.S. Merchant Marine Academy, and as head men's and women's volleyball coach at Pratt Institute. A middle blocker at UNC Charlotte, she earned All-Sun Belt and All-Metro Conference honors and, as a senior, ranked second in NCAA Division I in attack percentage, and she later played professionally in Switzerland and the United States. She holds a bachelor's degree in English literature from UNC Charlotte and a master's degree in physical education from Columbia University.
Table of contents
This article was written with assistance from the Achievable team.
For a high school athlete, the first personal message from a college coach can feel like the finish line. It isn't. Being recruited and being admitted are two separate tracks, and at selective colleges, from the Ivy League to highly selective Division III schools, plenty of strong athletes learn that the hard way. The students who come out of the process happiest tend to be the ones who understood how it works early, kept their grades and test scores strong, and chose a program as carefully as the coaches chose them.
This article walks through the difference between being recruited and being admitted, the academic standards every athlete has to meet, how to plan from eighth and ninth grade, the questions to ask coaches, what balancing a sport and college classes really looks like, the options for students who aren't recruited, and how to get noticed instead of waiting to be found.
Recruited and admitted are two different things
Being recruited means a college coach is giving a student attention the school doesn't give the general student population: personal messages, calls, invitations to visit, letters written just for them. The NCAA describes a student as recruited once a coach contacts them off campus, pays for a campus visit, or, in Divisions I and II, makes a written offer of athletics aid. Recruiting can begin as early as ninth grade, though for most students it starts in 11th grade.
Being admitted means the college has said yes to the student as a student, through its admissions office. That decision follows its own process, and a coach's interest doesn't replace it. The NESCAC, a conference of highly selective Division III colleges, puts it plainly in its admissions statement: its coaches recruit student-athletes and "act as advocates for them," but "no coach at any NESCAC college has the authority to offer, promise, or otherwise guarantee a spot in the incoming class."
How much a coach can help also depends on the level. College sports run across NCAA Divisions I, II, and III, the NAIA, and junior colleges, and each works differently. In Division III, which doesn't offer athletic scholarships, a coach's main role in admissions is support: the coach can back a recruit's application, which a student applying on their own doesn't have. Some coaches have more influence than others, depending on the school and its conference's guidelines. In Division I, recruiting can be far more intense, especially at programs in the national top 25, where several schools may compete for the same athlete. The Ivy League plays in Division I but awards aid only on the basis of financial need, not athletic ability. Under the Ivy schools' joint agreement, coaches may tell the admissions office they support a recruit, and an admissions office may send a recruited athlete a "likely letter," no earlier than October 1 of senior year, that has the same effect as an admission letter. But only the admissions office can make or communicate an admissions decision, and what a coach says, out loud or in writing, isn't a binding commitment.
Academics always matter, even for top recruits
A common myth says that a student good enough to play in college will get in no matter what. Grades and test scores always matter, and some standards are fixed before a student can even play. To compete in Division I, a student needs 16 NCAA-approved core courses, with 10 of them (seven in English, math, or science) finished before the start of senior year, and a core-course GPA of at least 2.3. Division II also requires 16 core courses, with a minimum 2.2 GPA. The NCAA Eligibility Center checks these requirements, and students register with it during high school.
One rule has changed. In January 2023, Divisions I and II removed SAT and ACT scores from the NCAA's eligibility requirements for students enrolling from August 2023 on. But the NCAA itself notes that colleges may still require test scores for admission or scholarships, and at selective colleges they often do. A recruited athlete applying to a school that requires or values scores still needs a strong SAT or ACT, and it helps to choose the right test early and know which colleges superscore. That's fair, too: athletes are applying alongside non-athletes who are trying to get into the same competitive schools on their academics alone.
Start planning in eighth and ninth grade
When to start depends on the student. Some students know early exactly where they want to go: it's been their dream school for years, maybe a parent went there, and they already know which dorm they want. Some athletes are recruited very early, too. Either way, eighth grade is a good time to start thinking about what the student wants from college, and ninth grade is the time to lay out a real plan for which classes they'll need. A loose plan by the start of high school matters, because missing one required class can leave a student scrambling to catch up in the spring of senior year, which is always hard.
A good place to start is the student's list of colleges, however long it is. Twenty, thirty, or fifty schools is fine at the beginning. Cross-referencing what each one requires shows whether anything is missing, and it says a lot about which majors and programs suit the student. If a program the student likes is heavy on science or math and those subjects are a real struggle, it's better to find that out now. A student shouldn't ignore a hard subject entirely, but if none of the schools or programs on the list require a course like calculus, and the student is finding it miserable, there's no need to force it. Part of high school is learning what you're good at, what challenges you, and what you'd rather not spend your time on.
For athletes, the plan works best as three tiers. The NCAA's core-course requirements are the minimum for everyone who wants to play in Division I or II. Next come the admission requirements of the colleges on the list, and then the requirements of the specific programs the student is interested in. Building a high school schedule around all three keeps every option open. Homeschooled athletes have a few extra steps, covered in our guide to qualifying for the NCAA as a homeschooled student.
Questions to ask coaches before you commit
A coach who really wants a student on the team will be transparent and in regular contact throughout the process, keeping the family in the loop about what the coach is doing and what the student needs to do next. That steady communication is itself a signal of how important the student is to the program.
Students should also do their own homework. Visit schools in person rather than relying on virtual tours, AI summaries, or a best friend's opinion (our guide to making every campus visit count helps). Meet the head coach more than once, and talk to the assistant coaches, current players, graduates of the program, and players who left it. It's easy to be blinded by the brand of a school, a coach, or a team's stars, when the real questions are whether the environment fits, whether the student matches the coach's personality, and whether they get along with the players. Expect to hear both good and bad things about any program, in any sport, and take it all in to make an informed decision.
The most important questions are about academics. Ask the coach what time for schoolwork looks like when the team is on the road, in the middle of the season, or in the playoffs, when a student might miss tests, presentations, or other important dates. Ask what relationship the program has with the academic side of the university. A good coach should have a good answer. Then ask the players the same questions, and find out what graduates of the team have gone on to do and whether they felt good about both their academic and team experiences.
Balancing a sport and academics in college
During a competitive season, the balance will tip toward athletics. That's part of the deal. But a good coach makes academics a priority anyway, with support and structure that help players stay successful in the classroom. The rest comes down to the student's own choices. One college volleyball player got advice from a senior teammate that stayed with her for her whole career: you can play, you can study, and you can party, but you can't do all three, so pick two. Study and play, and you're probably in good shape. Play and party, and your academics will suffer. Taking that advice to heart helped her have a very successful academic career.
The level of play shapes the balance too. At a top program in the country, the team usually becomes a player's social life. Most players aren't at a top-five or top-25 Division I program, though, and at other levels there is often more room for a social life. In Division III, a fall sport like volleyball takes over the fall, but NCAA rules sharply limit how much a team can practice outside its championship season. That leaves the spring open to study abroad, take an internship, or explore other parts of college life.
College sport can also be one of the longest and best classes a student ever takes. Beyond skills and experience, it builds leadership, close relationships, and an understanding of how teams work, and managing a sport alongside classes has a lot in common with holding a job or running a big campus organization. Eligibility is changing as well: in June 2026, Division I adopted an age-based model that gives athletes up to five years of eligibility, without a separate limit on seasons, if they enroll by the academic year after their 19th birthday. It applies in full to students who first enroll in fall 2027 or later. College sports have changed quickly in the last few years, so it pays to stay adaptable.
If you aren't recruited, you can still play
Not every student who loves a sport is recruited. Maybe the skills aren't at that level yet, maybe the student doesn't want to devote that much time to it, or maybe their preferred school's team is so competitive that there isn't a spot. There are still several ways to play.
A preferred walk-on is a student who wasn't recruited and doesn't receive a scholarship, but whose skills suggest they could contribute. The coach may have a spot for them, or they may still need to try out. A regular walk-on is a student the coach knows nothing about who shows up to a tryout and earns a place on the team. That's rare, but it happens.
Club sports and intramurals are the other options. Intramural teams compete within the university, while club teams often compete against other colleges, and some are very competitive. In one example, a strong club volleyball player who got into UCLA joined its club team rather than the varsity team. The club played at a high level, but it also adapted to her schedule as a serious pre-med student, so when she couldn't make a practice or a match, that was fine. As with every other part of this process, the right choice depends on the student's goals.
Don't wait to be found
A student who thinks they're good enough to play in college and is waiting for coaches to call needs to get to work. If a coach hasn't reached out, there are only two reasons: the coach doesn't think there's a spot for the student's skill level, or the coach hasn't seen them play. The second one is fixable. About 8.3 million students played high school sports in 2024-25, while the NCAA has a little more than 500,000 college athletes, and coaches have limited time to find the players they want.
So students need to advocate for themselves: email and call coaches, stay in consistent contact, and give coaches a way to see them play, through a highlight video or an invitation to a practice or tournament. A student who is serious about being recruited should treat it like a part-time job, with consistent effort (Joan Casey's guide to proactive recruiting outreach covers more of it). And students should write those emails themselves rather than leaning on AI. Coaches receive a huge volume of messages, they can tell when one is a mass email written by ChatGPT, and they are trying to get to know the student: whether they can coach them and whether they'll fit the team. A genuine message that lets the student's personality come through does far more than a polished one that could have come from anyone.

