Achievable logo
Achievable blue logo on white background

How to overcome imposter syndrome in grad school

Imposter syndrome often peaks during GRE prep and the first year of grad school. A career strategist explains where it comes from and the strategies that help.
Emmanuela Stanislaus, PhD's profile picture
Emmanuela Stanislaus, PhD
10 Nov 2026, 9 min read
Achievable blue logo on white background
Digital illustration of a graduate student looking into a mirror that reflects her in a graduation cap and gown holding a diploma, representing seeing past imposter syndrome to her real ability
Achievable
Achievable blue logo on white background
Emmanuela Stanislaus, PhD's profile picture
Founder and Lead Consultant, Dr. Emmanuela Consulting LLC

Dr. Emmanuela Stanislaus is a career and higher education professional passionate about helping students and young professionals navigate graduate school, career development, networking, and an evolving job market. With experience in higher education and career development, she brings a student-centered approach to helping individuals identify opportunities, build meaningful professional connections, and confidently navigate their academic and career journeys.

Connect:

This article was written with assistance from the Achievable team.

Plenty of people preparing for the GRE know the feeling. A practice score comes back lower than expected, a forum is full of applicants with near-perfect scores, and a quiet voice says everyone else belongs in graduate school and you don't. The voice often gets louder after the acceptance letter arrives, in the first seminar, the first meeting with an advisor, or the first time a professor's expectations are unclear.

Dr. Emmanuela Stanislaus has spent about 17 years in higher education and almost six years working closely with graduate students, many of them first-generation students who are highly capable but unsure how to read the hidden rules of academia and the job market. She has also lived imposter syndrome herself. This article covers what it is, where it comes from, why the institution is sometimes part of the problem, and the practical strategies that help, from GRE prep through the first year of a program. For her take on whether and when a graduate degree is worth it, see her earlier article on weighing the graduate degree.


What is imposter syndrome?

Dr. Emmanuela draws on the work of psychologist Lisa Orbé-Austin, co-author of Own Your Greatness, who describes imposter syndrome as the experience of feeling like a fraud even when you are capable and experienced. It happens at every level. Despite their credentials and success, people with imposter syndrome struggle to internalize their accomplishments. The idea goes back to psychologists Pauline Clance and Suzanne Imes, who in 1978 described the "impostor phenomenon" after working with more than 150 high-achieving women, many of whom held PhDs or were recognized for their academic excellence, yet believed they weren't really bright.

Despite the name, imposter syndrome is not a clinical diagnosis. A 2020 systematic review in the Journal of General Internal Medicine notes that it does not appear in the DSM or the ICD. It is a pattern of thinking, not a disorder, but it still has real costs.

Left unaddressed, those feelings can lead to career stagnation and a lot of emotional distress. People keep undervaluing themselves. They overwork, hoping that more effort will finally make them feel confident or get the results they want, and end up burned out instead. They avoid growth opportunities and sabotage themselves in small ways. For a GRE student, that can look like studying past the point of diminishing returns, putting off the test date again and again, or leaving a reach program off the list without ever applying. The sense of inadequacy is not rooted in reality, and it is hard to untangle alone: a coach, a therapist, or another support system can help someone recognize the pattern and break it.


How common is it?

Very. In a 2020 KPMG study of 750 high-performing executive women, 75% said they had experienced imposter syndrome at some point in their careers. And it isn't limited to women or to executives: the systematic review above found the condition common among both men and women, at ages from adolescence to late career, with reported rates ranging widely, from 9% to 82%, depending on how it was measured. Rates were particularly high among ethnic minority groups.

Dr. Emmanuela is clear that she is not a therapist. Her perspective comes from her own experience, from working with graduate students who have faced it, and from her research. And in her experience, people don't grow out of imposter syndrome. She still experiences it herself. What changes is that people learn to recognize when the behaviors are showing up and find ways to handle them.


Where imposter syndrome shows up

Imposter syndrome tends to appear in three kinds of situations: unfamiliar spaces, spaces where a person is underrepresented, and spaces with unclear expectations. Graduate school is all three at once for many students, and so is the early part of a career. Perfectionism, comparison, and outside pressure fuel it.

The application process is a good example. Nobody hands applicants a rulebook for what a strong file looks like, how a GRE score will be read, or what faculty want to see in a statement of purpose. That uncertainty is easy to read as a personal shortcoming. It helps to replace guesswork with information: our guides to what a good GRE score is and the grad school application timeline make the unwritten rules a little more written.


When the institution is part of the problem

Dr. Emmanuela sees two sides to imposter syndrome. One is internal: navigating spaces that make a person feel they don't belong. The other comes from what researchers call institutional agents: the faculty, administrators, and leaders who act on behalf of an institution. Sometimes what these people say and do genuinely makes students feel they don't belong. When they don't explain expectations clearly, or aren't transparent about what it takes to get from point A to point B, students tend to internalize that uncertainty as a personal inadequacy rather than recognizing it as a normal part of learning, or as a failure of the people who should be guiding them. That falls hardest on first-generation students, who have no one at home who has navigated the system before.

Dr. Emmanuela experienced this while earning her doctorate. She was working full-time in higher education administration and studying part-time, and she told a faculty advisor she was interested in pursuing a faculty career. He told her it was too late, with no explanation, and she couldn't get any more from him. As a first-generation college student whose parents immigrated to the U.S. and couldn't help her navigate the education system, she was left wondering what she had done wrong, and whether bias against full-time employees was at play. After the conversation she was very anxious. Talking it through with her husband helped her recognize the anxiety for what it was and get help. Through therapy, she learned to stop interpreting institutional silence as personal failure and to reclaim confidence in the value she brought to the space.

For students, the lesson is to separate self-worth from unclear expectations, bias, or a lack of mentorship in a program. It also helps to look for programs and advisors who are transparent before enrolling: reaching out to faculty early, as described in our article on faculty outreach, and knowing how to vet a department's inclusion and support.


Find your community

The biggest step, in Dr. Emmanuela's view, is talking to people. Community can save people from themselves: from the negative self-talk and self-doubt that grow in isolation. When people describe what they are feeling, others can open their eyes to something they are too close to see. Hearing similar stories from peers also shows that it isn't just you, which helps a person stop treating the feeling as a personal flaw. The KPMG study points the same way: 72% of the executive women looked to the advice of a mentor or trusted advisor when they doubted their abilities to take on new roles, and 32% said they identified with imposter syndrome because they didn't know others in a similar place.

A second opinion matters too. No one should take a single person's word about their ability, especially when that person is the source of the doubt. For GRE students, community can be a study group or a friend preparing for the same test. For new graduate students, it is the cohort, a peer mentor a year or two ahead, or a campus counseling center.


Separate thoughts from truth

Thoughts drive behavior, so Dr. Emmanuela encourages people to ask two questions when self-doubt hits: what story am I telling myself right now, and what evidence actually supports it? A thought like "I feel so dumb right now" rarely survives the second question. The evidence usually says the opposite: the person has done the coursework, earned the degree, passed the exam, or learned the material. Imposter thoughts are a narrative, not facts.

Writing down accomplishments, in a journal or a running list, gives people something to return to when they feel they are losing their grip on reality. For applicants, that record has a second use: it is the raw material for a grad school personal statement and for the notes that help recommenders write strong letters. During GRE prep, a log of practice test results works the same way: a score that has climbed over several practice tests is evidence, not a feeling.


Ground yourself in the present

Imposter thoughts tend to pull people into the past, replaying what went wrong, or into the future, predicting what will go wrong. One exercise Dr. Emmanuela learned from her own coaches is to ground herself through the five senses: what can you see around you, what can you smell and hear, what can you feel (the coolness of the air, for example), and what can you taste, or would like to taste? It brings a person back to the present moment and to what is real.

Because the worst cases people imagine are usually far from reality, she also uses that imagination on purpose. Ask: so what if that does happen? What then? And what can I do now to prepare if it does? Having a plan for an outcome that will most likely never happen helps the mind calm down. Breathwork helps with that too, and it travels well to test day: our article on meditation and the GRE covers simple ways to start.


Talk to yourself with kindness

Dr. Emmanuela keeps a photo of herself at about three years old near her. When intrusive thoughts show up, she asks whether she would really talk to that little girl that way, and what she could say instead that would make young Emmanuela feel secure and loved in that moment. She also keeps sticky notes with affirmations around her desk as reminders of who she is. Some people may roll their eyes at affirmations, but they are worth trying.

Kindness also means pushing back on the idea that worth is measured by constant productivity. Stillness in the day is not failure, and admission was not a fluke. Students are in graduate school, or applying, for a reason. The first year of a program will bring new rooms and new expectations, and imposter feelings may come back with each one. That is normal, and the same tools still work.


Not feeling like you belong doesn't mean you don't belong

Imposter syndrome isn't always internal. Sometimes it is a rational response to unclear systems and unequal access. That's why Dr. Emmanuela pairs personal strategies with a clear-eyed view of the environment: talk to people, check your thoughts against the evidence, come back to the present, and treat yourself with the kindness you would offer anyone else. Feeling out of place in a GRE prep forum, an admissions process, or a first seminar is a common experience, and it says nothing about whether you belong there.

Emmanuela Stanislaus, PhD's profile picture
Emmanuela Stanislaus, PhD
10 Nov 2026, 9 min read
Achievable's profile picture
Achievable
Reviewer
Achievable white logo on blue background
Achievable GRE - $199
Hit your GRE target score on the first try with Achievable's interactive online exam preparation course. Includes everything you need: 950+ practice questions with unlimited quantitative practice, an easy-to-understand online textbook, 30 timed verbal / reading comprehension sections, 250 vocabulary words, and unlimited instant essay grading.
30 timed Verbal sections, unlimited Quant
950+ practice questions with explanations
Up to 8 more points, or your money back
Unlimited Issue essays, scored instantly
Screenshot of the Achievable GRE course dashboard